RC RANDOM CHAOS

Why Social Programs Usually Don't Deliver

· via Hacker News

Original source

We need more goat sacrifices

Hacker News →

The author argues that policymakers should approach major initiatives with humility, recognizing that many well-intentioned programs produce zero measurable impact. He catalogs examples across the political spectrum: a $3 billion Congressional school improvement initiative, Chief Diversity Officers hired by universities without increasing diversity, a $280 million Afghan women’s employment program with unclear outcomes, One Laptop Per Child (zero academic effect), and various unsuccessful education and social programs. The pattern holds across ideological lines—from failed school grants and vaccine campaigns to unsuccessful Medicaid reform and abstinence education.

The article draws on sociologist Peter Rossi’s 1987 ‘Iron Law of Evaluation,’ a satirical paper arguing that large social programs have zero expected net impact. Though Rossi later tried to distance himself from this conclusion, he acknowledged that we still don’t know whether programs work across different domains. The author demonstrates that truly effective programs are surprisingly difficult to identify; even previously celebrated policies like the Earned Income Tax Credit are now questioned due to publication bias and methodological issues that allow unreliable findings to dominate entire research literatures.

The core problem isn’t just that programs fail, but that researchers struggle to identify which ones work. One-off studies prove little when statistical manipulation is common and methodologies don’t reliably replicate. The author uses the classic ‘Illusion of Control’ psychology study from 1975 as a cautionary tale, showing how researchers misinterpreted why people valued football cards differently—overlooking the simpler explanation that people prefer their favorite players.

Read the full article

Continue reading at Hacker News →

This is an AI-generated summary. Read the original for the full story.