Python Steering Council Halts Experimental JIT Compiler
Python’s just-in-time compiler, added to CPython in the 3.13 release in 2024, will be removed. The steering council halted the feature in June and requested a standards-track proposal that would justify its continued presence, specifying maintenance obligations, compatibility standards, and concrete performance targets. The JIT maintainers created PEP 836 to meet this requirement, but after the council’s September review found it fell short, the authors withdrew the proposal entirely.
The council’s fundamental issue was inadequate planning and insufficient consensus building. The proposal failed to clearly specify who would maintain the JIT long-term, what performance gains users could expect, or how the project would handle situations where JIT-enabled Python behaved differently from standard Python—a crucial concern given how much existing code relies on interpreter quirks. Security considerations and memory overhead were underexplored. The council also demanded that compatibility testing begin immediately rather than in 2028, and run as an ongoing process rather than a single checkpoint.
Experimental code in the main branch creates persistent friction for library developers and end users due to shifting behavior and API changes. The JIT team argued that PEP 836 needed to present implementation plans alongside goals; abstract requirements without context made little sense. The council disagreed, wanting clear consensus among Python’s broader developer community before endorsing further experimentation—something the revised proposal never achieved.
Read the full article
Continue reading at Hacker News →This is an AI-generated summary. Read the original for the full story.