RC RANDOM CHAOS

NYT sues Brave for paywall bypass and AI content sales

· via Ars Technica

Original source

NYT demands Brave shut down its paywall blocker and end deals with AI firms

Ars Technica →

Brave Software faces a lawsuit from the New York Times and allied publishers over its practice of circumventing paywalls and supplying scraped content to artificial intelligence companies. The complaint names Anthropic, Perplexity, Mistral, xAI, and Cohere as recipients of Brave’s indexed material through paid API access. Publishers allege Brave has generated over $100 million from this operation while providing no compensation to news outlets or journalists.

Brave stacks multiple revenue streams on the same harvested content. The browser includes a default paywall-bypass setting, giving users free access to paywalled articles. Simultaneously, Brave blocks publishers’ advertising and displays its own ads, sharing revenue with users while cutting news organizations out of transactions. AI firms pay separately for search index access, creating a third income source extracted from journalism Brave did not create.

The lawsuit alleges direct copyright infringement through content scraping, contributory infringement for enabling AI firms’ use of the material, and vicarious infringement through profit-sharing. The complaint also cites Digital Millennium Copyright Act violations for circumventing access controls. The case raises a fundamental question about AI’s data requirements: whether machine-learning systems require licensing and payment, or whether technology companies can treat published journalism as freely available raw material.

Read the full article

Continue reading at Ars Technica →

This is an AI-generated summary. Read the original for the full story.