RC RANDOM CHAOS

Mandating Bot Identity Won't Solve Scraping Harms

· via Hacker News

Original source

Breaking the open web won't stop the bad bots

Hacker News →

Proposed federal and state bills would require web crawlers to disclose their identity and stated purpose when accessing websites. The push comes from real damages: AI training scrapers extract enormous content volumes, depriving publishers of traffic, revenue, and server resources. Media companies have made this case to policymakers.

Requiring disclosure misses the core problem and damages legitimate automation. Identity alone is meaningless—a disclosed company could still hammer servers with excessive requests while staying compliant. More critically, much valuable web scraping depends on anonymity: investigative journalists uncovering malfeasance, researchers studying online discrimination, archivists preserving digital history, disability advocates auditing website accessibility, and public health researchers tracking epidemics all need opacity for their work to function. When research subjects know they’re being observed and by whom, their behavior shifts.

Existing laws—privacy statutes, copyright doctrine, consumer protection rules—already provide tools to address specific harms from misused scraped data. Technical standards bodies are developing protocols for managing machine access. If lawmakers believe new rules are necessary, they should focus on conduct that causes measurable damage—excessive server load, fraud, or data collection for prohibited purposes—rather than penalizing anonymity itself.

Read the full article

Continue reading at Hacker News →

This is an AI-generated summary. Read the original for the full story.