RC RANDOM CHAOS

Home Assistant's Pwned-Password Check Sparks Privacy Backlash

· via Hacker News

Original source

I never authorized an integration that scans my secrets

Hacker News →

A GitHub issue in Home Assistant’s documentation repo escalated after a user objected to the platform’s built-in pwned-password check, arguing it ran without explicit opt-in and could be abused by a threat actor with repo access. The feature, part of the Supervisor for years, flags app credentials marked as passwords by cross-referencing them against Have I Been Pwned. A recent release fixed a warning that made the check visible to users for the first time, triggering the complaint. The mechanism is designed to be privacy-preserving: the Supervisor hashes secrets locally with SHA-1, transmits only the first five characters of the hash to HIBP, receives back all matching prefix hashes, and performs the comparison on the local instance. The check can be disabled with ha security options --pwned=false.

The maintainer initially closed the issue as “won’t fix” and dismissed the privacy concern, comparing it to 1Password’s similar feature. A red-team specialist pushed back hard, calling the lack of opt-in a design flaw and threatening to enumerate abuse vectors. The thread was locked as too heated. The maintainer later returned with an apology, acknowledged the documentation gap, confirmed the disable command, and committed to updating the relevant page to explain the mechanism and opt-out path.

Read the full article

Continue reading at Hacker News →

This is an AI-generated summary. Read the original for the full story.