Eugene Police Demand $2.5M to Release Officer Misconduct Records
Original source
Oregon Police Are Charging a Local News Outlet $2.5M for Records About One Cop
Hacker News →When Double Sided Media requested records about Eugene, Oregon police officer Justin Peckels—who allegedly punched a resident during a traffic stop—the city responded with a $2.5 million bill. The police department claimed processing would require 44,816 hours of work. The outlet’s separate request for records on another officer brought an additional $195,869.52 estimate. The city justified these costs by insisting it must search all personnel records across every city department, rejecting the standard practice of narrowing searches to relevant custodians. This appears designed to make the request unaffordable rather than reflecting genuine processing costs.
The Eugene case reflects a broader pattern. The Department of Defense previously quoted 15 million hours and $660 million to process a FOIA request, while the DEA estimated $1.46 million for records about El Chapo’s capture. Local agencies exploit weaker protections compared to federal ones, routinely ignoring state provisions allowing fee waivers for public interest disclosure. The irony is stark: Eugene’s police department recently signed a two-year $342,000 contract for nearly 60 AI-powered Flock license plate readers, demonstrating technological sophistication when it suits departmental interests. That same capability apparently vanishes when journalists request accountability records, suddenly making basic keyword searches prohibitively complex.
Without legislative action requiring fee caps, public-interest waivers for journalists, and mandatory efficient record systems, departments will continue using inflated bills to suppress oversight.
Read the full article
Continue reading at Hacker News →This is an AI-generated summary. Read the original for the full story.