RC RANDOM CHAOS

Beyond Job Training: What Education Is Really For

· via Hacker News

Original source

What shall I teach my son?

Hacker News →

A programmer expecting his first child questions whether traditional education serves its purpose when his own skillset—programming—suddenly feels less economically valuable. Drawing on Neil Postman’s 1995 book “The End of Education,” he traces how schools have survived repeated waves of technological disruption meant to replace them: Edison’s failed predictions about radio and film, incorrect forecasts about MOOCs upending higher education, and current uncertainty around AI capabilities.

Education has endured because it serves multiple overlapping purposes that shift with social needs: developing good character, building citizenship, enabling people to earn livelihoods, improving the world, and transmitting knowledge. The author previously defined education as cultivating “resourcefulness”—the ability to use available tools to solve problems—but observes this concept is now embodied in AI agents with tool loops. Recent advances in AI mathematics have placed previously reliable paths to success under pressure: college dropouts like Jobs and Gates who found market validation, or exceptional minds like Einstein whose scientific contributions bypassed credential requirements. The author worries about what opportunities remain for his children if these alternative routes become foreclosed.

Rather than accept education’s decline, the author embraces Postman’s proposed alternative purposes: collective stewardship (“Spaceship Earth”), revival of curiosity about American democratic ideals, and inviting students to actively shape the tools and narratives that subsequently shape them. He concludes that teaching method often matters more than content, and that relating to children as human collaborators rather than objects to be shaped—figuring out education’s purpose together—offers the most honest path forward.

Read the full article

Continue reading at Hacker News →

This is an AI-generated summary. Read the original for the full story.