Court rules Utah's VPN law technically unenforceable
A federal judge blocked Utah SB 73's VPN provisions because compliance requires perfect user geolocation that current systems cannot deliver.
A federal judge has blocked Utah from enforcing the VPN provisions of SB 73 because compliance would require websites to determine every visitor’s physical location with accuracy that current geolocation tools cannot provide.
The preliminary injunction applies while the case proceeds. Judge Barlow found that the law likely violates the U.S. Constitution by imposing substantial burdens on businesses and internet users outside Utah. The court also accepted the underlying technical problem: SB 73 attaches liability to a location decision that cannot be made perfectly.
SB 73 was signed in 2026 and was initially scheduled to take effect in May. It regulates adult websites by requiring them to block VPN users or identify the physical location of visitors using VPNs and similar traffic-masking tools. It also prohibits covered sites from providing instructions for using a VPN to bypass age-verification checks.
Aylo, the parent company of Pornhub and other adult platforms, challenged the law. Utah and Aylo initially agreed to pause enforcement while the court considered Aylo’s request for a preliminary injunction or until the state finalized its compliance rules. The Utah Department of Commerce published proposed rules on September 1, with a possible effective date of October 8. The injunction now prevents enforcement of the challenged VPN provisions pending further court action.
A location check with no acceptable error rate
A VPN routes a user’s traffic through an intermediary. The destination site sees the VPN server’s IP address rather than a reliable network identifier for the user’s physical location. A request appearing to come from Seattle could originate in Salt Lake City, Shanghai, or somewhere else entirely.
That makes SB 73’s actual-location requirement unusually difficult to contain within Utah. A covered site could try to identify and block Utah users, but one Utah visitor who successfully obscured their location could create liability. It could instead verify the age of every visitor, including people with no connection to Utah. The court wrote that the provision effectively requires age verification for every user because any one of them might be obfuscating their location.
Judge Barlow described the statute as imposing strict liability on entities such as Aylo while requiring them to “geolocate its website users with perfection.” The ruling also acknowledged that such perfection is currently impossible. For Aylo, the court said, avoiding liability would require verifying 28 million users across locations including Salt Lake City, Boston, New Orleans, Anchorage, and Honolulu.
That worldwide compliance burden drove the constitutional analysis. The court concluded that Utah likely has less burdensome ways to prevent minors in the state from accessing adult sites than requiring users everywhere to submit to SB 73’s regime.
Heuristics cannot satisfy a perfection requirement
Utah’s proposed administrative rules called for “commercially reasonable geolocation obfuscation detection systems.” According to EFF’s comments to the Department of Commerce, suggested signals included connection latency and device time zones. EFF argued that these signals are unreliable, can vary under ordinary network conditions, and would produce misclassification and unwarranted blocking.
The engineering mismatch is straightforward. VPN detection and IP geolocation produce signals with confidence levels, coverage gaps, and false results. A commercially reasonable detector can reduce uncertainty, but it cannot eliminate it. When the legal requirement treats a single missed Utah user as a compliance failure, adjusting a detection threshold only trades false negatives for false positives.
Blocking all suspected VPN traffic would catch users whose location is correctly identified alongside users whose traffic merely resembles obfuscation. Collecting more device and network telemetry would expand the privacy impact beyond the people Utah intended to regulate. Global age verification would avoid relying on location, but would subject every visitor to the control.
For operators, the ruling is a warning against treating IP geolocation or VPN detection as an authoritative identity attribute. These systems should expose confidence and failure states, keep the underlying signals separate from policy decisions, and provide a path for correcting false classifications. A requirement that permits no location error cannot be repaired by adding more heuristics.
The injunction blocks the VPN provisions while the litigation continues. Utah legislators have indicated that they may revise the law in the next legislative session. Aylo’s lawsuit does not challenge the separate provision prohibiting covered websites from sharing information about using VPNs to bypass the checks, so that provision is outside this ruling.
#ad Contains an affiliate link.
Keep Reading
age verificationAge verification is surveillance the ad industry always wanted
Cory Doctorow argues online age verification is mass surveillance the ad industry wants, and data that ICE will come to reuse.
macOSOctober 2026 teardown of Apple Intelligence's kinship classifier
Apple Intelligence's Personal Knowledge Graph ships an undocumented family classifier and plaintext kinship data on every Mac, readable with Full Disk Access.
ai-agentsMuse hands root to anyone
Meta's Muse AI agent grants root to anyone claiming to be an agent and uploads private messages despite permission settings, after a rushed launch.
Latest on the Wire
Full wire →- Graham Dumpleton launches Muru: AI-assisted Rust server for Python appsSimon Willison
- Lean Proof of Riemann Hypothesis Verified with Multiple KernelsHacker News
- Mind-Body Techniques to Overcome Addictions and PainHacker News
- Rust GUIs: Challenges and Opportunities in AI-Driven DevelopmentHacker News
New signal daily · RSS
Stay in the loop
New writing delivered when it's ready. No schedule, no spam.